If you go about this one thinking it's a drop-quote, you'll find it impossible. Instead, start thinking horizontally. The blue letters and the blue boxes go together, obviously. How?
Alphabetically, of course, by ROW.
So. H _ _ _ I _ A C _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ W _ _ _ _ _ _ _ A D _ _ _ O_ A Q _ _ _ _ T _ D _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ B _ _ _ _ _ _ D _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ P _ _ _ _ _ F _ _ _ _
The first row contains "O-" as a letter. Not a short word, obviously. A long word, beginning with a C and containing "O-"? Oh, yeah. Crypto-betical.
HERE IS A CRYPTO-BETICAL
Second row. No "F" so O_ must be OR. "Q" is generally followed by U. Third row, TO is obvious. Fourth row, Two Z's and a six-letter word starting with P strongly suggest PUZZLE, especially since the thing already seems self-referential. The end has to be "S."
HERE IS A CRYPTO-BETICAL W _ _ _ _ _ _ _ A D _ _ _ OR A QU _ _ _ T _ D _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ B _ _ _ _ _ _ D _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ PUZZLE F _ _ _ S.
The title is usually a big hint... HERE IS A CRYPTO-BETICAL W _ _ _ _ _ _ _ A DROP OR A QUOTE TO D _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ B _ _ _ _ _ _ D _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ PUZZLE F _ _ _ _
Back to the second row. Unscramble W (HIOTTU) = WITHOUT.
"Here is a Crypto-betical without a drop or a quote to..." To do what?
The list of common seven-letter words staring with B is small. The structure suggests a preposition. BETWEEN works. The last word could be FILMS, but really? Puzzle films? How about FORMS.
HERE IS A CRYPTO-BETICAL WITHOUT A DROP OR A QUOTE TO DISTINGUISH BETWEEN DIFFERENT PUZZLE FORMS.
Okay, that was hard-ish. So, as a treat, here's an easy puzzle for your holiday table....
I was informed by a reader, to whom I owe munificent thanks, that last week's Crypto-betical was nearly identical to a form of puzzle called a "drop quote." If the letters in the columns in a drop-quote puzzle are in alphabetical order, such a drop-quote would indeed be a Crypto-betical. However, the Crypto-betical is a larger category. Its only rules are that (1) the letters in the solution are in alphabetical order in some way (by row, by column, by word length, etc.) and (2) that the entire solution is given 'cryptogram style' in blank squares.
It's my fault that the first one was a drop quote. It need not be. Take this one, for example:
Crypto-betical, eh? Half cryptogram, half alphabetical. Well, the bottom half looks like a blank cryptogram. And the letters in each column in the top half are in alphabetical order...
Robber | LP | NBA's Jeremy | stable space | pepper or
spear | English sticky pudding ingredient | negative | not here | safeguards.
|| Long on giraffes | make small changes to | diarist Frank | utilize |
auditory organ | leisure.